Showing posts with label SEWA. Show all posts
Showing posts with label SEWA. Show all posts

Monday, March 9, 2009

Dheroli and Chacher














Early on, I remarked that India was a land of extremes. A couple weeks ago, I saw Mumbai’s antithesis: the villages of Dheroli and Chacher. Despite the presence of a few tractors, most farming here is done the old-fashioned way: with bullock-pulled plows/carts and manual labor. The area is peaceful, picturesque and incredibly green.

To get there, Abhay (our project assistant) and I took a series of buses to Bordeli and then took a car for the last 30-40 kilometers. On the drive, we passed fields of cotton, castor and corn, acres of the greenest banana plantations, and a series of overloaded trucks, bullock carts and rickshaws. I was glued to the window and so absorbed in the scenery that I hardly noticed the lack of shock absorbers on our rented van or the blaring old Filmi music our driver insisted on blasting on his old cassette deck.

The main purpose of our trip was to meet with some of SEWA's members and conduct a few focus groups for the price information project. We wanted to learn how they’re using the futures prices we’re giving them to make their planting or selling decisions, and what we need to do to improve the program in subsequent seasons. On the price information project, not everyone participating would be considered poor, so there was some variety in the livelihoods of the people with whom we spoke. In fact, the largest farmer had almost 30 acres of land. Some of the homes in the village are mud huts, while the house where we held the Dheroli focus group was 200 years old and was owned by Prameenbhai, one of the larger and most experienced farmers. Despite the diversity in the group, each village seemed more like an extended family (and to some extent, it probably was).

Most of our questions centered on how farmers make their planting, growing, harvesting and selling decisions, as well as how the market is structured (places where they sell their crop, to whom they sell it and whether the process is an auction, private negotiation or something else). I've noticed that if I ask a yes or no question, people are reluctant to give a negative answer, perhaps feeling that saying 'no' would offend us. This is sometimes obvious when the 'yes' response is inconsistent with other things they've already said. There's some literature on this, which I won't get into.

Even though we asked them a continuous stream of questions for two hours, everyone was extremely gracious to us. Villagers came to meet us promptly, and of course, the tea flowed abudantly. The Sarpanch of Chacher village (the chairperson of the village's governement) told me "you are most welcome here anytime." Which is nice, since I might want to retire there one day.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

The future and spot of price information

I worked more on our futures/spot prices project this week. I'm blown away by the ingenuity of the program and its potential, but the concept is fairly simple.

An overwhelming majority of the world’s poor rely on agriculture for subsistence. For these households, output risk and price risk constitute major obstacles to asset accumulation. Because farmers operate on thin margins and are often in debt, negative price shocks can have devastating consequences. The small farmers at the origin of the supply chain --the people who are the most vulnerable to these shocks-- face a host of difficult investment decisions with significant consequences for themselves. Farmers’ choices about which crops to sow, when to sow them, whether to invest in high-yield seed or fertilizer, when to harvest, and when and where to sell the output can mean the difference between meager subsistence and profitability.

Unfortunately, small-scale farmers in developing countries like India often have only imprecise knowledge of market prices, and even less ability to predict prices into the future. These inefficiencies at the origin of the supply chain also affect overall agricultural productivity. The recent increase in commodities prices presents both challenges and opportunities for developing countries: food prices have escalated, but on the other hand, farmers could potentially earn more. Realizing the opportunity, however, depends on markets functioning well and, in turn, on individuals making efficient decisions about planting, harvesting, and selling their crops.

This is where our project comes in. Our goal is to supply future price information to farmers on their specific crops so that they can make more informed predictions of which crops will be most profitable in the coming seasons. Additionally, after the harvest, we will provide spot prices at their various local markets for the crops they are selling. This lets the farmers know which market to take the crop to without wasting money shipping their crops from one market to the next (typically, small farmers pool their resources to hire a truck).

Having more efficient production and distribution benefits farmers by increasing incomes for those who depend on agriculture for their livelihoods, and benefit everyone, by reducing wastage, increasing output, reducing prices, and potentially lowering volatility. 

In 2003, the Indian government legalized futures in all agricultural commodities, leading to the establishment of two large exchanges in Mumbai. These unfolding changes are spurring dramatic growth in futures volume and the range of contracts available, with large farmers gaining access to trading and market information.

The futures market is at the center of a vigorous policy debate in India. In particular, critics of the commodity exchanges often claim that futures speculation has caused increases in the price of food grains. Although a government commission appointed to investigate this claim came back with mixed findings, it is not surprising that futures markets have come under fire in India.

I'll write again soon with more details about how we're actually diseminating the price information.