Showing posts with label Centre for Microfinance. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Centre for Microfinance. Show all posts

Monday, March 9, 2009

Dheroli and Chacher














Early on, I remarked that India was a land of extremes. A couple weeks ago, I saw Mumbai’s antithesis: the villages of Dheroli and Chacher. Despite the presence of a few tractors, most farming here is done the old-fashioned way: with bullock-pulled plows/carts and manual labor. The area is peaceful, picturesque and incredibly green.

To get there, Abhay (our project assistant) and I took a series of buses to Bordeli and then took a car for the last 30-40 kilometers. On the drive, we passed fields of cotton, castor and corn, acres of the greenest banana plantations, and a series of overloaded trucks, bullock carts and rickshaws. I was glued to the window and so absorbed in the scenery that I hardly noticed the lack of shock absorbers on our rented van or the blaring old Filmi music our driver insisted on blasting on his old cassette deck.

The main purpose of our trip was to meet with some of SEWA's members and conduct a few focus groups for the price information project. We wanted to learn how they’re using the futures prices we’re giving them to make their planting or selling decisions, and what we need to do to improve the program in subsequent seasons. On the price information project, not everyone participating would be considered poor, so there was some variety in the livelihoods of the people with whom we spoke. In fact, the largest farmer had almost 30 acres of land. Some of the homes in the village are mud huts, while the house where we held the Dheroli focus group was 200 years old and was owned by Prameenbhai, one of the larger and most experienced farmers. Despite the diversity in the group, each village seemed more like an extended family (and to some extent, it probably was).

Most of our questions centered on how farmers make their planting, growing, harvesting and selling decisions, as well as how the market is structured (places where they sell their crop, to whom they sell it and whether the process is an auction, private negotiation or something else). I've noticed that if I ask a yes or no question, people are reluctant to give a negative answer, perhaps feeling that saying 'no' would offend us. This is sometimes obvious when the 'yes' response is inconsistent with other things they've already said. There's some literature on this, which I won't get into.

Even though we asked them a continuous stream of questions for two hours, everyone was extremely gracious to us. Villagers came to meet us promptly, and of course, the tea flowed abudantly. The Sarpanch of Chacher village (the chairperson of the village's governement) told me "you are most welcome here anytime." Which is nice, since I might want to retire there one day.

Thursday, March 5, 2009

You must laugh now

This afternoon I gave a presentation on CMF and two of our current projects at a workshop hosted by Saath. The workshop was held at the Nehru Foundation, which has an amazing, green campus. I'd occassionally get distracted from the other presentations by a monkey that was sitting cross-legged in an eerily human manner, on a tree branch right outside the window next to me.

The presentations were in Hindi, Gujarati and English, though everyone made slides in English. This was my first time presenting with a translator and it made for an interesting experience. At times, the translator would paraphrase what I said and then translate what was on the slide. In a couple of cases, he actually got ahead of me. I wonder what exactly he was saying at times, as it didn't sound like what I had said.

All this reminds me of a story President Carter told when I heard him give a speech at Stanford back in 2003 or 2004. Shortly after leaving office, President Carter was touring some villages in Japan. He had some downtime during the visit and a local school approached him about speaking at their graduation. Not wanting to disappoint, Carter accepted and proceeded to craft his speech. After four years in office, Carter was used to giving speeches and having them translated. He was also aware that humor didn't always translate well, so he chose only one joke, which he whittled down to its most basic form.

At the graduation ceremony, President Carter gave his speech as planned. When he got to the joke, he listened as the abridged English version became even more brief when the Japanese translator recited it. The crowd roared with laughter -- a much better reaction than the joke had ever received before. President Carter was startled by the reaction and he approached the translator afterwards to find out exactly how he said it, so that he could improve the English version in the future.

At first, the translator was hesitant to say anything. Carter pressed on, eager to know how to ellicit such a positive response again in the future. Finally, the translator admitted, "When you told joke, I tell the audience 'President Carter said a joke. Everybody must laugh now.'"

Saturday, February 28, 2009

Incensed!

It’s been a busy few weeks packed with several field visits to the Ahmedabad slums and villages in rural Gujarat. Something has been eating at me all week. And it isn’t whatever was in my bed at ‘Hotel Sketchy’ in Bordeli during my village visits last week.

It’s Shilpaben, a middle-aged woman who lives in the predominantly-Muslim slum of Juhapura on the southern side of Gujarat. To call Shilpaben a working mother would be quite the understatement. On top of working all day to provide for her family, Shilpaben helps prepare meals for some of her community’s most malnourished children as a member of Saath’s Jeevan Daan (literally “Gift of Life”) program. Just as a quick aside: Saath is one of the MFI’s that we’re partnering with, and their Jeevan Daan program helps mothers prepare more nutritious meals for their families, particularly by helping them understand which foods are both cheap and nutritious.

All day long, Shilpaben makes incense sticks, rolling them individually by hand. In a single day, she makes about 3,000 of them, which she sells to a wholesaler who packages them into boxes of 12 and then sells. For every 1,000 sticks that Shilpaben makes, the wholesaler pays her 12 rupees (about 25 cents), so she earns about Rs. 36 per day (75 cents). The wholesaler, on the other hand, sells boxes of 12 sticks for Rs. 10-15 (about 20-30 cents)…more than 70 times the price he pays Shilpaben!

As a result, Shilpaben is living on less than a dollar a day instead of potentially $50 per day (the price all 3,000 sticks at the wholesaler’s price). I’m both outraged and confused that a seemingly simple problem exists here (though of course I don’t know the whole story). Even if Shilpaben is a much better incense stick maker than incense stick saleswoman, isn’t there some amount of time she should spend trying to sell her sticks to consumers? Wouldn’t the incense sticks still fetch a good price if they were tied with a ribbon instead of put in a box? And if everything from milk to soap is sold door-to-door, why can’t incense sticks be too?

Sunday, February 15, 2009

Early Morning Fun

If I had to list the things I least expected to be doing in India, near the top would be: appearing as a backup dancer in Shahrukh Khan's next film, learning to drive on the streets of Ahmedabad, and playing a game of ultimate frisbee. Well, I couldn't even handle the beginner moves at Basement Bhangra, so SRK will have to go it without me. And if I'm alive and writing, I certainly haven't gotten behind the wheel in India yet.


As it turns out, every Sunday morning (at 7:30am) some of the kids from the underprivileged areas of Ahmedabad come to a field next to Ghandiji's Sabarmati Ashram to play a bit of ultimate frisbee. The idea was the brainchild of some of the folks from Indicorps, who figured they could give kids from the poorer areas of Ahmedabad something to look forward to each week by getting them interested in a supposedly-non-contact team sport. So after one failed attempt the week before to wake myself early enough to get there, I—along with Dixie—grabbed a rickshaw and headed across the city.


I was assuming we'd find a pretty informal game with maybe enough kids and volunteers to field the two teams. I definitely wasn't planning on running drills or seeing 8-yr olds throw forehands and backhands. About twenty-five to thirty boys and girls showed up, some as young as six years old, some in their teens. We had enough in each age group to break them into groups depending on their size and skill, which was a good thing since the little ones would probably have been lifted off the ground if they had tried to catch the heat being thrown by the older kids.



It was quickly obvious that these kids had been practicing their throws and drills for a while. As I understand it, the goal is to eventually organize a friendly tournament in Ahmedabad to give them a competitive outlet. The older kids in particular seemed to really enjoy the competition.


While I migrated from running drills with the older kids to throwing to the youngest group, Dixie sat out most of the morning with a sore ankle, but snapped a ton of pictures for us. Our favorites are posted on our Picasa page: http://picasaweb.google.com/kaizad.cama/RunningSlideshow20082009. Predictably, the kids flocked to Dixie, especially the girls. The kids were excited to be in front of the camera, some of them striking their best Indian actress look or picking up nearby clay pots with which to pose. In fact, it wasn't just the kids who were excited to have their pictures taken; their chaperone, and even an old gentleman named Rajbhai, who stopped Dixie later that morning at a snack stand, asked for their pictures to be taken. We have no way of tracking down Rajbhai, but happily for the children, Dixie has developed the pictures for them (she'll do anything to get kids' love…it's like an addiction!).


I'm not a morning person, but this made for a really memorable (if slightly exhausting day) even before starting our planned afternoon trip to see the ancient stepwell of Adalaj. I'm hoping we'll be able to go a few more times, but we're doing a lot of traveling on the weekends for the remainder of our trip. For anyone spending a weekend in Ahmedabad, it's definitely worth checking out.

Thursday, February 5, 2009

The future and spot of price information

I worked more on our futures/spot prices project this week. I'm blown away by the ingenuity of the program and its potential, but the concept is fairly simple.

An overwhelming majority of the world’s poor rely on agriculture for subsistence. For these households, output risk and price risk constitute major obstacles to asset accumulation. Because farmers operate on thin margins and are often in debt, negative price shocks can have devastating consequences. The small farmers at the origin of the supply chain --the people who are the most vulnerable to these shocks-- face a host of difficult investment decisions with significant consequences for themselves. Farmers’ choices about which crops to sow, when to sow them, whether to invest in high-yield seed or fertilizer, when to harvest, and when and where to sell the output can mean the difference between meager subsistence and profitability.

Unfortunately, small-scale farmers in developing countries like India often have only imprecise knowledge of market prices, and even less ability to predict prices into the future. These inefficiencies at the origin of the supply chain also affect overall agricultural productivity. The recent increase in commodities prices presents both challenges and opportunities for developing countries: food prices have escalated, but on the other hand, farmers could potentially earn more. Realizing the opportunity, however, depends on markets functioning well and, in turn, on individuals making efficient decisions about planting, harvesting, and selling their crops.

This is where our project comes in. Our goal is to supply future price information to farmers on their specific crops so that they can make more informed predictions of which crops will be most profitable in the coming seasons. Additionally, after the harvest, we will provide spot prices at their various local markets for the crops they are selling. This lets the farmers know which market to take the crop to without wasting money shipping their crops from one market to the next (typically, small farmers pool their resources to hire a truck).

Having more efficient production and distribution benefits farmers by increasing incomes for those who depend on agriculture for their livelihoods, and benefit everyone, by reducing wastage, increasing output, reducing prices, and potentially lowering volatility. 

In 2003, the Indian government legalized futures in all agricultural commodities, leading to the establishment of two large exchanges in Mumbai. These unfolding changes are spurring dramatic growth in futures volume and the range of contracts available, with large farmers gaining access to trading and market information.

The futures market is at the center of a vigorous policy debate in India. In particular, critics of the commodity exchanges often claim that futures speculation has caused increases in the price of food grains. Although a government commission appointed to investigate this claim came back with mixed findings, it is not surprising that futures markets have come under fire in India.

I'll write again soon with more details about how we're actually diseminating the price information.

Saturday, January 31, 2009

The First Ten Days

I’ve just about finished two weeks at the Centre for Microfinance. I’m splitting my time between three projects that are going on here. One is looking at whether giving farmers information about crop futures prices (via a billboard in the village or via a text message to their mobiles) will have any impact on their planting decisions, or whether spot prices at local markets will have an impact on where they take their crops to sell. The second project is looking at how different methods for teaching financial literacy affect the take up of the material (which is hopefully manifested in future financial decisions). The last project is trying to create a viable rainfall insurance contract that farmers want.

Each project offers a different side of microfinance. The financial literacy project obviously tackles a core issue for the poor that keeps them under-banked and outside of the traditional financial sector and MFIs, and leaves them vulnerable to predatory alternatives. The weather insurance project deals with risk management at the policy level and consumption smoothing at the member level. And finally, the project on price information looks at technologies that can improve the playing field for the poor by giving them the information they need to make more strategic decisions.

So far, the most interesting days have been the two afternoons that I was able to spend with some MFI clients outside the slums of Vasna and the Old City. We organized two informal focus groups with members of Saath, a local MFI with a strong emphasis on savings and asset building. Our goal was to better understand the members’ baseline financial literacy so that we could design a curriculum appropriate for them. The first group we met with consisted of mainly housewives while the second group was made up of rickshaw drivers and owners of small- or micro- businesses such as kite vending, scrap metal and egg wholesaler.

Most of the focus group attendees are illiterate, but extremely saavy. Alex Counts (the founder of the Grameen Foundation) talks about this survivorship bias that leads the poor to defy stereotypes and misconceptions about their capabilities. Those that are somehow surviving poverty must be smart, resourceful and brave – traits that seem to aptly characterize the people I met.

Despite their minimal schooling (especially among the women), they showed a higher-than-expected baseline financial literacy. One reason for this might be the length of their experience with Saath, as they certainly seem to have Saath’s emphasis on savings engrained in them. When asked what they would do with a small windfall of cash (eg. a small inheritance or an especially good day at work), most said they would save it to protect against a bad day’s earnings in the future. I was especially impressed by one lady, Vastuben, who said she would not only save the money, but use her additional savings to obtain a bigger loan through Saath. On one hand, it seemed risky for her to essentially double-down on her savings. On the other, it reminded me of a PowerPoint slide that Vikram Akula (founder of SKS Microfinance) showed. In his presentation, he showed that the poor were often able to get ROIs between 30% and 230%. Of course plenty of microbusinesses fail, but his point was that microbusinesses tend to produce better margins than traditional businesses because they can keep their costs down through the use of family labor, low infrastructure costs and no taxes or legal costs. So, assuming his assertion is true, that could make Vastuben a pretty astute money manager.